Blog Layout

A Short Story About a Main Contractor Who Liked to Levy Contra-Charges on His Subcontractors

Richard Hildrick

We are the Subcontractor's Friend who aims to overturn contra-charges which Main Contractor's unfairly deduct.
It is our Mission to Level the Playing Field for Subcontractors.

As a Subcontractor in construction, it is highly likely that you are only too familiar with the problem of contra-charges and other unjustified deductions from your account. The Main Contractor just takes your money as he likes and you feel powerless to do much about it.
The following short story might resonate with you and also provide you with the answer: Phone a friend.

Email Us: enquiries@rjhconsulting.co.uk
A QUICK STORY ABOUT A SUBCONTRACTOR AND A MAIN CONTRACTOR WHO LIKED TO LEVY CONTRA-CHARGES

The Main Contractor was a big boy with lots of friends working for him. The Subcontractor was honest, hard working, and just wanted to do a good job and get paid; construction was his game.

The Main Contractor said one thing but did another, he was friendly in conversation and yet unfriendly when he asked his QS to write e-mails and letters. He expected the Subcontractor to jump when told to jump, and to find extra labour whenever he decided they were needed, even though there was no need for more men.

The Main Contractor’s works were in a mess, because the design was poor and his site organisation was….well, what organisation? Inevitably, as usual, he was well behind his programme and facing a big bill for liquidated damages from his Client. So he threw money at the job, whilst his QS thought to himself “the Subbies would have to pay”, after all, “they are the ones doing all the work so it must be their fault that we are late and losing money”. The Main Contractor’s QS was very clever, and he was a legal expert, or so he said – and he would make sure that the Subcontractors paid.

The Subcontractor kept at his job, despite having to work haphazardly, and being forced to move around the site just to keep his men busy. What happened to the original programme of starting at one end of the job and working logically to the other? It just never happened, even from the beginning.

Then, towards the end of the job, the Subcontractor noticed that his payment applications were no longer being paid in full. His cash flow was suffering and at the same time the Main Contractor was still shouting for more men, and now for overtime working as well!

The Subcontractor noticed that each month the Main Contractor was deducting an increasing amount of contra-charges, and it seemed that the figures were plucked out of thin air, and strangely, added up to enough to make the Subcontractor’s payment next to nothing.

But what the Contractor didn’t realise was that the Subcontractor also had a friend. The friend was a big guy who knew his stuff; he explained that it was not the Subcontractor’s job to prove that the contra-charges were unjustified, the Main Contractor himself had to prove that his deductions were justified and correctly calculated. How could the Subcontractor disprove the figures anyway, he had little idea of how they had been made up.

The Subcontractor’s friend said he had seen this situation many times before, not to worry and to leave it to him - he would go with the Subcontractor to explain politely to the Main Contractor how things really were. He said that whenever he had gone with his other Subcontractor friends, to knock on a Main Contractor’s door to talk about contra-charges (armed with his weapon which he called Adjudication), the Subcontractor had always returned with a sack full of his previously unpaid money. So that’s what they did.

The moral of the story – Subcontractors, don’t put up with contra-charges and deductions from your account - Phone a big friend. Collect your cash, and get on with running your business.


E-Mail or call us now to Give Your Company an Unfair Advantage:

Call Us: 01347 811155
A man with a beard wearing a white shirt and purple tie
Richard Hildrick - Founder
BSc(Hons) MSc MRICS MCIOB FCIArb

A book titled 10 things you must know to avoid and resolve construction payment disputes
QS Dispute Resolution Construction Adjudication
August 21, 2024
How a Specialist Subcontractor Benefitted from Adding RJH to Its Team, and Upped its Commercial and Contractual Game Overnight.
Commercial Awareness for Subcontractors
August 20, 2024
Our workshops are tailored to each company’s requirements, ensuring you and your team get the most out of it, at a fixed price. One previous attendee said the workshop was: “Vital to anyone working in a commercial or project management role in construction, to understand the workings and thinking of main contractors today.”
NEC Contracts Early Warnings v Compensation Events
By Richard Hildrick August 19, 2024
NEC Contracts Early Warnings v Compensation Events
Adjudication
By Richard Hildrick July 24, 2024
The Power of Adjudication in the Right Hands Subcontractors often contact us only after months of wasted time and energy trying to get a Main Contractor to pay them - for Variations, for works completed, for extended prelims, or to release unjustified contra-charges or other deductions. They are usually extremely frustrated and often angry. And rightly so. Many Subcontractors even find that they can no longer even get hold of the Main Contractor’s staff who were previously so keen to talk to them about getting the work done. They are getting nowhere and in the meantime their cash remains in the Main Contractor’s hands. Our Subcontractor Clients tell us that their best decision was to call us rather than make another time-wasting call to the Main Contractor’s QS, who never answers anyway. Main Contractors don’t ignore our correspondence, they know that they can’t, because we have the power of adjudication up our sleeve, to deploy quickly and effectively on behalf of our Subcontractor Clients. And we have the experience required to obtain the best result for Subcontractors, at the minimum cost. A recent case for one of our Clients, a specialist Joinery Subcontractor, successfully addressed his inability to obtain payment of over £200,000 of contra-charge deductions from his account. Before our appointmant, the Main Contractor was adamant that he was entitled to keep all of this money, and wouldn’t entertain any of the Subcontractor’s efforts to resolve matters. However, once the Subcontractor made the wise decision to call RJH, we had his case in Adjudication within a week, and obtained an Adjudication Award for him within just over a month. The Adjudicator awarded our Subcontractor Client every penny of his £200,000+ by the way. The Subcontractor not only recovered his money, but also his valuable time which he can now direct towards running his business. And now he involves us from pre-contract stage to ensure that the risk of this happening again is minimised.
Employers Agent and Quantity Surveying Services
June 30, 2021
For our latest client, boxxe, we managed a £1m+ office redesign project commercially and operationally. The result was a sleek, modern and on-budget project, completed over a 30-week period.
commercial problems for subcontractors
By RJH Consulting April 15, 2021
Every project and problem is different. Yet in all the years we’ve spent supporting Subcontractors, there are some common issues that come up time and time again. As a Subcontractor in construction, it is highly likely that you are only too familiar with the these challenges, and causes of problems on your projects. We’ve highlighted the 20 most common commercial problems which we find that subcontractors struggle with, despite doing a great job on site and being experts in their trade. You can download them here:
Template documents for succesful Commercial Management for Subcontractors
April 15, 2021
Template Documents to make Subcontractor's lives easier when managing their projects.
The way that Subcontractors Must Charge VAT is Changing in March 2021
By Richard Hildrick February 10, 2021
Are you aware of the new reverse charge VAT rules coming into force from March 2021? 1st March 2021 will see the new reverse charge VAT rules for the construction industry being brought into force . Please contact Amanda amanda@rjhconsulting.co.uk if you would like us to send you some useful resources to guide you through the process, including: • Flowchart for PAYING A SUBCONTRACTOR • Flowchart for SUBCONTRACTORS • Sales invoice example taken from HMRC’s website NOTE: it is important to add the wording with regards to the reverse charge on your own invoice. What do you need to do? The new legislation has been brought in so that Subcontractors will no longer charge VAT to Contractors who are not end users of the subcontracting services they receive. The rules only apply to work carried out under the construction industry scheme (CIS) where both supplier and buyer are VAT and CIS registered. Are you a Subcontractor (supplier) who is NOT working for an end user? If you are VAT registered and carrying out work for a Building Contractor who is VAT registered and registered under CIS, you will no longer charge any VAT to the Contractor on your sales invoices – neither the labour nor materials. The vital points are that you are: 1. working for a CIS registered Contractor as a Subcontractor; and 2. both you and they are VAT registered. All these conditions must be met for the reverse charge to apply and VAT must no longer be charged. Do you employ sub-contractors under CIS as a contractor (buyer) and are NOT an end user? If you are VAT registered and so are your Subcontractor, they must no longer charge you VAT. Who is an end user? Contractors and Subcontractors will charge VAT as usual to end users, such as a domestic homeowner for whom you are building an extension or a manufacturer for whom you are building a warehouse. The Homeowner is neither a Contractor nor VAT registered, so a normal VAT invoice would be raised. The manufacturer may be VAT registered but is not a Contractor, so a normal VAT sales invoice would be raised. You do not need written notification they are an end user where it is obvious but always ask, just in case. It is possible for an end user to be VAT registered and CIS registered and, in this case, the reverse charge does not apply, VAT must be charged by the Subcontractor. This would occur if the end user employs you as a Subcontractor and there is no onward supply of yours or their building services. An example of an end user who is both CIS and VAT registered might be a housing developer building homes to sell on. You will need some sort of written notification (letter/contract/email) from your customer (the Contractor) to state that this is the case. If they are an end user, you must charge VAT. It is likely that large developers will have a good knowledge of the rules and will automatically guide you on how to bill them appropriately. CIS deductions The new VAT rules do not affect CIS deductions. They remain exactly the same as before with tax deducted from the sales invoice labour amount after VAT has been deducted. Where an invoice has no VAT added to it, the sales invoice total is now obviously the net amount for deductions purposes. Please contact Amanda amanda@rjhconsulting.co.uk if you would like us to send you some useful resources to guide you through the process, including: • Flowchart for PAYING A SUBCONTRACTOR • Flowchart for SUBCONTRACTORS • Sales invoice example taken from HMRC’s website NOTE: it is important to add the wording with regards to the reverse charge on your own invoice. RJH Commercial Consulting is sharing this HMRC information as a guide and for information purposes only, this document does not constitute advice or recommendations, please visit the HMRC website for full details.
By Richard Hildrick October 9, 2020
“There has been a very welcome understanding from RJH of our unique funding condition which has necessarily changed the order of approach for the project, that a regular project might not reflect. RJH also has a robust approach defending our position and achieving our objectives when dealing with all the contractors, quietly and effectively invoked. We also have comfort that there is experience in dispute resolution which should prevent out project requiring those services, and we have benefited from the consistency of working with one person throughout.” – Richard Mole. Project Co-Ordinator, Trustees of Driffield Methodist Church
By Richard Hildrick April 24, 2020
“RJH advice and recommendations have been invaluable throughout this contract. With their guidance we have achieved an excellent result with an amicable final account agreement with our client. We would have no hesitation recommending RJH and plan to engage them on other complex contracts.” – John Taylor, Managing Director F.B.Taylor (Cable Contractors) Ltd.
More Posts
Share by: